YouTube Rewind 2018: What Went Wrong?


vidIQ
vidIQ

QOTD: Why do you think YouTube Rewind has so many dislikes?

Vor 12 Tage
Taylor Brost
Taylor Brost

It did not represent the 2018 YouTube community, even Casey Niestat is not very relevant anymore, although it is also becoming a meme because of dislikes now

Vor 4 Tage
Tim B
Tim B

Maybe it's because over time Youtube, through demonetization of channels, removal and censorship of conservative content and overall changes to the platform, has became less of a community and more of an ad-fueled communist dictatorship with Susan Wojicki and her Youtube cronies at the top, every channel with 20 million+ subscribers at the middle, and everyone else at the bottom. If Youtube had not gone political with their platform and inside the YT rewind (plus the amount of Fortnite cringe and disconnection from the viewers (everyone controls rewind but youtube controlled who got on)), maybe it would have more likes than dislikes like in the beginning. Maybe 2019's rewind is going to be worse. In addition, the Rewind didn't address the most important issue of this year - Pewdiepie vs. T-Series. It was nice that his chair was at least in the video. 99% of the Youtubers in the video were ones I don't watch or don't even know. If they [Youtube] could have put more well-known youtubers in and not focus on obscure, not well-known Youtubers speaking various languages.

Vor 5 Tage
SlimeyCommand 25
SlimeyCommand 25

Becuz there no pewdiepie, they never seen the battle of the youtubers

Vor 5 Tage
Jim Bråthen
Jim Bråthen

Because it's one massive circlejerk to try to appeal to such a minority fanbase that it's no longer logical. They are so disconnected With both their audience and their own content creators that there was no doubt from the start that they would dislike the video. It also has next to no actual youtubers within it, as a result of Youtube becoming such a hivemind that anything and everyone that do not comply With their political agenda gets demonetized or straight up ignored. This year's youtube rewind was highlighted by will smith, Trevor noah, and John Oliver, People whose only fame relevant to youtube is because their videos from other sites get posted there, they have nothing to do With youtube or it's content creation culture, they are merely pretty stickers that can be pasted on to better market the video. This flaw is all the more empowered by the fact that the main cast this year consisted of twitch streamers and ex-viners, along With such a forced attempt at diversity and multiculturalism that half the People in it did not even speak English, and had to be subtitled as they all read the script of youtube's own political agenda. Along With lackluster content, the fornite, the football, the royal wedding, and all of 3 relevant memes, the Worst part of all was the abrupt pause in the middle of the video where everyone figuratively circlejerks over how P.C they are, talking about immigrants, drag Queens, single mothers and more, and how brave they all are for being what they are, it's such blatant echochambering that it almost comes off as the kind of parody 4chan would Write about youtube rewind, except this was made in Complete sincerity by youtube themselves. To round off my rant, here's a friendly reminder of the actual youtube content creators we did not get: pewdipie, markiplier, shane, Threadbanger. Jacksepticeye, Smosh, Vsauce, Game Theory, KSI, Jake Paul, Howtobasic, The Slow Mo Guys, Ricegum, The King Of Random, Jontron, Rhett And Link, Guava Juice, Game Grumps, A Stan Lee mention, or Stefan Stefanson, or Stephen Hawking, or Stephen Hillenburg. As for memes/relevant content we did not get: Absolute Unit, Trump memes, Any political memes whatsoever, neither left or right, Tide Pods, Slimes, Any challenge whatsoever except foil ball, Change My Mind meme, Star wars, Halloween memes, Pewdipie vs T-Series, Any video game memes at all, Distracted boyfriend, Ugandan Knuckles, Steamed Hams, Thanos, Phil Swift/Flex tape, Making knives out of weird materials, Detective Pikachu, Toy story, or really any popular memes of 2018 whatsoever. And THAT... is why Youtube rewind has now become the single most disliked video ever.

Vor 5 Tage
Euro
Euro

Yes because YouTube became to SJW and forgot the YouTube Gods and added more random people

Vor 5 Tage
Jannis Kolb
Jannis Kolb

Change the thumbnail to 13M

Vor 22 Stunden
Cris Garcia 6
Cris Garcia 6

YouTube should remove Premiere

Vor Tag
vidIQ
vidIQ

Why do you think that?

Vor 11 Stunden
Cgle
Cgle

13 million dislikes*

Vor Tag
sup names idk
sup names idk

I think people have shitty taste in videos

Vor Tag
Matthew Lee
Matthew Lee

There's one thing this video needed: An emotional tribute. But not to creators like Stan Lee or Stefan Karl Steffanson. But vague mentions of sad people.

Vor Tag
Adaept Zulander
Adaept Zulander

It's not "haters". You either don't know what you are talking about or you are a paid shill.

Vor 2 Tage
Daily Dose Of Migue
Daily Dose Of Migue

Updated , YouTube Rewind Sits At 13M Dislikes 🤦🏻‍♂️ Yikes

Vor 2 Tage
Franshisk
Franshisk

There's never going to be a good YTR

Vor 2 Tage
Eevee Shipper
Eevee Shipper

They should at least say that the song is Idol from Bts and not just Kpop and people got sad cuz they thought that they would be able to see Bts. >:(

Vor 2 Tage
Lundmark Wanpen
Lundmark Wanpen

1:56

Vor 2 Tage
YAYEETOWO
YAYEETOWO

your just as ignorant as youtube

Vor 3 Tage
Insub0rdination AJ
Insub0rdination AJ

It hit over 12 million dislikes and 2.2 million likes. I disliked it because it was sickening and cringy. And for many reasons stated. 😑

Vor 3 Tage
Eetu Jokinen
Eetu Jokinen

I think that it's hated just because of Fortnite (and I understand why)

Vor 3 Tage
Ellhulto Games
Ellhulto Games

The answer is easy......they "forgot" abuot Trash-Series vs PewDiePie

Vor 3 Tage
Yukiteru Amanoレッドドラゴ
Yukiteru Amanoレッドドラゴ

It's because within each year this site slowly gets disconnected with its content creators and YouTube forget they even exist, plus it was just awful to watch.

Vor 3 Tage
Bob Bob
Bob Bob

Here’s my constructive thought; stop saying premier like a yank. It sounds weird. Why are you saying it like that anyway?

Vor 3 Tage
DrSketchDoodles
DrSketchDoodles

I feel like if a YouTuber that was in rewind 2018 says he/she didn't like it, YouTube would punish them.

Vor 3 Tage
Guccicakes
Guccicakes

at this point people are just jumping in on the bandwagon nd disliking for the sake of others, dont get me wrong it was terrible, however most people just dislike the video without even watching it

Vor 4 Tage
Sunrise:Joey Roblox
Sunrise:Joey Roblox

Now it hit 11 Million

Vor 4 Tage
Aisu
Aisu

you didn't answer question in the title... thumbs down

Vor 4 Tage
John Thomson
John Thomson

IT IS ALREADY 12 MILLIONS, BUT YOUR THUMBNAIL SAYS 10 MILLIONS. CHANGE THE THUMBNAIL YOU LAZY BRIT!! 😂

Vor 4 Tage
BROJANGSTER
BROJANGSTER

There were so many dislikes because the Rewind was AWFUL!! FIGURE IT OUT, DUDE!!

Vor 4 Tage
y miller
y miller

The video is a complete disconnect from the consumers and creators

Vor 4 Tage
Paola Pao
Paola Pao

Why does youtube rewind has lots of dislikes?

Vor 4 Tage
InfinityGameCosmic
InfinityGameCosmic

Actually the 2018 YouTube rewind video are extremely cringe and the fact that pewdiepie was not in the rewind make everybody very unhappy (also 80% of all the YouTubers in the rewind video are actually not that well known)and that's why everybody hit the dislike button

Vor 4 Tage
mister x
mister x

Why, in the name of everything who's holy on this Earth, anything after Donald Trump's election must be so politicized? I despise racism, sexism and all that stuff but, seriously, during the whole year I have seen nothing but that in every repetittive way possbile. Those cringy "youtubers" think this is 1968.

Vor 4 Tage
Lucky Glove
Lucky Glove

They ignored everything but fortnite battle royal

Vor 5 Tage
CallMeDiffuse
CallMeDiffuse

11*

Vor 5 Tage
Rohan Choudhary
Rohan Choudhary

ae ja na madarchod

Vor 5 Tage
Sumika Masuyama
Sumika Masuyama

Lol what if youtube demonized every hate video on YouTube rewind 2018

Vor 5 Tage
PEEPERS ONLY
PEEPERS ONLY

10 million dislikes yay

Vor 5 Tage
Filip Kasprzyk
Filip Kasprzyk

Short answer: *E v e r y t h i n g*

Vor 5 Tage
Xiouq
Xiouq

This video is exactly why you weren’t invited and or not in the video

Vor 5 Tage
Tex Martin
Tex Martin

Everything

Vor 5 Tage
Techno Arafat
Techno Arafat

I never cringed so hard in YouTube Rewind

Vor 5 Tage
just a random guy who likes rock music
just a random guy who likes rock music

I just want to see funny crappy 10 second to 2 minute vidoes/memes. That's what I want.

Vor 5 Tage
Blerpidy Blerp
Blerpidy Blerp

they went wrong when they didnt have pewdiepie i mean have you seen his subreddit before rewind

Vor 5 Tage
BigAlex1sBig
BigAlex1sBig

It passed baby its now the most disliked video update the thumbnail

Vor 6 Tage
Knightspy3
Knightspy3

UPDATE YOUR THUMBNAIL NOW, YR HAS MADE PASSED BABY IN DISLIKES sorry for all caps

Vor 6 Tage
Dejan Vezmar
Dejan Vezmar

Dont blame this on "Haters" here are the reasons to dislike this YTR. -AdPocylpse -No Pewdiepie vs Tseries -No MrBeast -SJW politics -safe family freindly creators -No H3H3 -No Jacksepticeye -Tooo much fortnite -Will smith (Actor)(i never watched his videos and most other havent) -Political speakers -BTS(Youtube deleted their views) -No KSI vs LoganPaul -BigShaq was a meme in 2017 so why did they put him in now?!?! -Empowering of women -Ninja (Not a youtuber...hes a twitch streamer) -Yoddling kid (a meme for a week then pewds reviewed it) -Only recognised 5 people out of 100's

Vor 6 Tage
Dejan Vezmar
Dejan Vezmar

Time to update....10 million dislikes

Vor 6 Tage
Matt Bochicchio
Matt Bochicchio

So many things happened in 2018 but the video was mostly fortnite...smh

Vor 6 Tage
Kiwi Is A Carrot
Kiwi Is A Carrot

Who would want Baby Shark in rewind? Who wanted Fortnite? Half of this year's rewind is about sending a positive message. The other half is Fortnite, Baby Shark, Will Smith and random things that the rewind "needs". The only thing they knew we wanted was the animators, but they only get like 2.5 seconds each, sometimes reappearing for another 2.5 up to 4 seconds.

Vor 6 Tage
Keith. X
Keith. X

It's 9.7 mil now

Vor 6 Tage
Frieder Zacharias
Frieder Zacharias

In my opinion it kinda makes me cringe seeing all the vine stars as well as the top “talked about” things of that year get excluded but that might just be me

Vor 6 Tage
Old Random Computing
Old Random Computing

9.4 million dislikes as of now...

Vor 6 Tage
Mami Devil
Mami Devil

It's really sad they didn't let any of us talk. It's like they don't care about us at all.

Vor 6 Tage
Fabulous5
Fabulous5

What went wrong? - Pretty much everything.

Vor 6 Tage
Comic Blaster
Comic Blaster

Better question: "YouTube Rewind 2018: What went right?"

Vor 6 Tage
R603 Burakkusuta
R603 Burakkusuta

There is a damn good reason for the hate. Cucktube has gone full sjw feminazi cunttard

Vor 6 Tage
Papa Daniel
Papa Daniel

0:45 Hugh Mungus what?! *Triggered*

Vor 6 Tage
Rampo Light
Rampo Light

amd thet will say that, because we release the video while pewds and t series are fighting for first slot ..

Vor 6 Tage
Faizan Hashmi
Faizan Hashmi

9m dislikes update ur thumbnail

Vor 6 Tage
Rampo Light
Rampo Light

LETS GO TO INDIA!! LETS KIDNAP THE INDIAN FAMILY CEO OF YOUTUBE!! THEY TURNING BLIND EYE ON PEOPLE!!!!.....

Vor 6 Tage
IM A BANANA
IM A BANANA

I don't even friken know who you are however it showed in my notifications.....I think YouTube got som many dislikes it hanged itself *cough* where's Logan *cough*

Vor 6 Tage
Jannis Kolb
Jannis Kolb

9 mil so far 😉

Vor 6 Tage
TheBurning Skull
TheBurning Skull

Title:what went wrong to the rewind Me:Everything, everything went wrong

Vor 6 Tage
TeLcH
TeLcH

they didn't put anything about the pewdiepie tseries war? just fully ignore?

Vor 6 Tage
AlfieProGame’s Channel
AlfieProGame’s Channel

Answer:Possibly (and definitely!) everything.

Vor 6 Tage
Ayten Anne
Ayten Anne

Would you visit my chann el and support me,please?

Vor 6 Tage
SkyVenomZero
SkyVenomZero

Hey man, Youtube rewind reached 9 million dislikes

Vor 6 Tage
TheReaLyss-t
TheReaLyss-t

9.2 mill

Vor 6 Tage
Potato_moon 12
Potato_moon 12

Everyone controls rewind Are you sure about that?

Vor 6 Tage
Carl Mannerheim
Carl Mannerheim

Getting close to that 10m dislikes. Took Justin Biebers Baby 10 years to get 10m dislikes it takes rewind just a month

Vor 6 Tage
Jayden Iglesias
Jayden Iglesias

Answer: Everything

Vor 6 Tage
explore the universe!
explore the universe!

because of communism.

Vor 6 Tage
Jaboi Deej
Jaboi Deej

They knew they screwed up before it went live at all smh

Vor 6 Tage
Scarzzz
Scarzzz

It was literally just a fortnite rewind.. youtube needs to learn da wae

Vor 6 Tage
TheRealAnthony
TheRealAnthony

The 2018 rewind barely covered what happened this year, and I mean the really important things. The fortnite bit was good, but after that I felt lost. People I’ve never seen before, only a couple of people I actually recognize, no idea what content was shown to me. I think people just didnt like it this year. It’s no hate train, it’s just most of the people just didn’t like it. Sure people do hate on it for nothing, but it’s not as much as people actually not liking it. P.s.- 99% of the viewers clicked off the video when kpop made its way into the video

Vor 6 Tage
Adam Zillin
Adam Zillin

2018 Rewind was utter cancer. What a bloated, convoluted garbage creation that’s so far out of touch with its creators it’s cringeworthy.

Vor 6 Tage
ImAlcazy
ImAlcazy

One awnser Everything

Vor 6 Tage
S A
S A

I like the video YouTube rewind video 2018 im just wondering why has it have alot dislikes? Well I think people think its chringy.the parts that I like is the music. But rewind 2018 man thats a lot of dislikes. .-. (Idk what im saying lol).

Vor 7 Tage
SpreaddJam
SpreaddJam

Dont forget to read the biased top comments of the creators hahahahaha

Vor 7 Tage
Gengar Gamr
Gengar Gamr

Cringe cringe and cringe is the problem

Vor 7 Tage
R screen
R screen

Lol, he has to keep changing the thumbnail

Vor 7 Tage
dequacker
dequacker

Tbh though rewind could have been better, doing rewinds today is way harder than 2012. Back then YouTube would have trends everyone would be involved in and videos everyone would see. YouTube had a main audience with content everyone would recognise. Now though YouTube is way bigger and the creators are so diverse with their content and so is the stuff viewers watch. So trying to sum up an entire year of a huge website into one video is gonna fail. YouTube is harder to define and fewer youtubers are being famous in all circles, and then they get scandals and can't be shown in the rewind. YouTube rewind just needs to either adapt or die. TL;DR Rewind could've been better but nowadays YouTube is too big and too diverse to make one video summarising the entire website in a year.

Vor 7 Tage
Ben Lovelace
Ben Lovelace

well the biggest reason they keep getting worse like-dislike ratios is because they keep getting worse, and YouTube keeps getting further away from the community and what it wants.

Vor 7 Tage
LOW ELO TV
LOW ELO TV

As the saying goes "Baby" is bad "Despashit" is bad "Fortnite" is bad (hello hate) "Dame tu cosita" is bad But Youtube Rewind is even worse

Vor 7 Tage
Cgle
Cgle

LOW ELO TV uM fOrTnItE iS tHe BeSt GaMe Of AlL tImE

Vor Tag
kreadiv
kreadiv

They had dialogue

Vor 7 Tage
Crypt Cr3ature
Crypt Cr3ature

Personally I think there's just a lot more people upset with YT as it's become more and more focused on promoting corporations and les about being a platform for the people to express their creativity like it use to be.

Vor 7 Tage
Shir0_1
Shir0_1

(speech inbound) It wasn't made for the viewers. It was made fir advertisers and corporations. They ignored much of the year's important events, such as the boxing matches, the Shane Dawson docs, and the Pewdiepie vs. T-Series battle. They pushed their "core values" and diversity that it became stifling. It's not like I don't agree with them, it's just that it went on forever. Instead of highlighting creators like Markiplier and Jacksepticeye who pushed for positivity, they went for clickbait, controversy, and money. Honestly, this was only to be expected, as when the platform got big enough to make money off of, the corporations moved in to corrupt it.

Vor 7 Tage
Tadas Boicovas
Tadas Boicovas

All I'm gonna say is YT Rewind deserves every dislike it gets

Vor 7 Tage
inari the fox
inari the fox

"muh it's the haters" No youtube rewind is easily the worst video on youtube right now, it's just complete garbage filled with ad-friendly content, as many stated, yt rewind is not for the creators but for the advertisers, that's what went wrong.

Vor 7 Tage
Artoria Pendragon
Artoria Pendragon

It was just bad, not all of it but lot of it was. The preachy and forced social justice messages. I like Will Smith but he's not what I think when I think YouTube. I'm sure Will would like to see Fortnite in a rewind 🙄

Vor 7 Tage
Sebastian Gomez
Sebastian Gomez

What went wrong? Fortnite!

Vor 7 Tage
liar Shaikh
liar Shaikh

Bcz indian was added don't add them YouTube they are fucker

Vor 7 Tage
Thomas F
Thomas F

I was extremely disappointed when I didn't see a Shane docu-series reference. Shane really changed the game on YouTube for that one but they disregarded it.

Vor 7 Tage
Ailsa Maclaren
Ailsa Maclaren

Because they didn't include Shane Dawson!!!! He had a crazy year this year and grew so much in following especially with his Jake Paul series. Even tho he is on a break right now they should have at least referenced his several hugely successful series which got millions of views each

Vor 7 Tage
iAm Stoopid
iAm Stoopid

Its not because of the haters, its because it doesnt really represent 2018...... 2017 lacks many things but 2018 lacks too much......

Vor 7 Tage
Shin Hidalgo
Shin Hidalgo

2018 is the worst year of my life because of youtube rewind 2018

Vor 7 Tage
Jacob Cariño
Jacob Cariño

hello we are so close to 10m

Vor 7 Tage
The Only One
The Only One

This is wrong

Vor 7 Tage
sterlker
sterlker

8.1 mil dislikes currently. It's gonna surpass baby anytime soon

Vor 7 Tage
The nutsy patootsie
The nutsy patootsie

There were absolutely NO TRIBUTES to those who passed this year

Vor 7 Tage
Anym
Anym

Everything.

Vor 7 Tage
JestfullHypnotist
JestfullHypnotist

No, I'm not a hater. Ive always enjoyed rewind. Even 2017 wasnt that bad to me. But this one is just bad. I watched the full video, made my opinion, an disliked it. I didnt even know about all of the hate it would get when clicking dislike. You cant just blaim this on "mindless haters"

Vor 7 Tage
Soki Moh
Soki Moh

Fortnite,bonfire talk and baby shark mostly the reason why 2018 rewind suck........... Ballss!!!!

Vor 7 Tage
Asher Joseph
Asher Joseph

I’m still confused as to what was happening in YouTube rewind

Vor 7 Tage
Obstriegel
Obstriegel

Because it's another video to push the libertard agenda. It's only about transgender and refugees

Vor 7 Tage

Nächstes Video